Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-36426936-20190602013601/@comment-38355399-20190602151935

If that's the case, I'll put some candidates:

Axol. Consider him second-worst character of SMG4 (On par with Tari). While he signifies the importance of the Ink Weaver, that's it. His personality feels and sounds kind of dead every time he speaks. Sure he can be friendly and good-natured, but that's a common trait/trope among many SMG4 protagonists at this point (shared with the three girls). He's an OC, which means he needs a more precise execution curve to make him an effective character. I don't like him as a captive/protagonist, as I'd think he'd be much, much more effective using Francis as a pawn and him being the cause of all this destruction.

Boopkins. Again, a protagonist, but his personality is so much about anime it gets repetitive and annoying. He doesn't really play much into the plot of the anime arc, and he's just there as a filler protagonist (Tari and Saiko share the same flaws). I'd think being a comic relief/punching bag (Bob exploits this) would render his personality better. Kind of like the Yang to Bob's Yin. He's borderline one of the worst characters in my opinion, and he's definitely one of my least favorites. He's not funny anymore and is kind of a nuisance.

Jeeves: Being a semi-clone of Toadsworth, much of his tasks could be performed by means of his more prolific counterpart. While the Glass of Milk made him a more funny character, anything else could be done better with Toadsworth. I'm kind of glad he got shafted, but he could potentially function better as a egostistical villain.

Desti: Aside from solely being created as Meggy's rival, I consider her to perpetually be one of the worst charaters of SMG4. She's even less funny than Meggy, and her personality is extremely common and stereotypical: Your typical middle school bully. While the anime arc has slightly improved her, she's still shares a generic personality and is (in several ways) worse than Meggy, having even less funnny moments.

Honorable mentions: Francis, Yoshi, Peach.