Board Thread:Fun and Games/@comment-36596195-20180914015622/@comment-38355399-20190501002725

Found this thread a while ago. With that being said, I would like to post a tier list as well.

S tier: Swag, Chris, and Eggman outstand me with their humor. Swag and Chris mix together to make the perfect duo for GNR humor, though recently they're slightly nerf from the anime arc placements. Eggman's just hilarious in Sonic the Derphog, with his more comedic personality eliciting LOLs.

A tier: Though Mark's a surprise, somehow hiring the Guards even after they've done a lot of stupid stuff makes me laugh and shake my head (in a good way) at the same time. Sonic, along with Eggman's rival Pootis complements Eggman's humor.

B tier: Though their appearances are less frequent, nevertheless appropriate moments of their personality make me enjoy them every time they air. SMG3 and Luigi continue to impress me to this day.

C tier: Mario's funny most of the time, but more recent episodes cause me to rank him down due to his more friendly/bland interactions with the more modern SMG4 cast. Everyone else are good gags, but they don't make me particuarly want to smile. They're good for comic relief at proper contexts.

D tier: The Multicolored Marios don't really have a concrete personality. Nevertheless, they're more enjoyable to see compared to the characters below. Wario and Steve, while posing as good comic relief, feel that they could have more screen time for their acts of comedy.

Low tiers, E and F: Most of them got nerfed pretty hard for the anime arc (especially on Peach, SMG4, Meggy, and Bob). They don't really do much to impress me, as most modern characters get used WAY too much to appeal to the younger fanbase's desires. They'd best be at least recurring characters, as to not make their screen time rough, bland, and repetitive. SMG4's voice clips, Peach's 180 decision, Bob being more friendly, and Meggy's bland personality all contributed into their downfalls. Everybody else's appearances feels like their defined personalities are reptitive (Yoshi and tax fraud, Waluigi and rejection, and Lakitu with his camera)

G tier: Boopkins turned from a funny and sympathetic character to an annoying pest with anime obsession. If you like anime, at least keep it down to infrequent mentions, not an arc that's poorly developed. Axol's voice clips and some of his facial expressions (as well as a missed opportunity to become a villain) made me hugely unimpressed. His emotions feel super lackluster, and it would be a little better if he got meme lines rather than actual voice clips. Saiko's the worst one so far, because her Japanese voice lines get dropped around so frequently, and she gets appearances that don't really suit her. Also, she'd be best as an annoying antagonist rather than a protagonist.