After Mario buys a can saying "Creepy Spaghetti" and eats it, he unknowingly makes his worst fears and some other creepypasta characters come to life, including a creepy Mario statue that won't stop bothering him.
Pennywise from the classic horror novel "IT" has come to attack the world of SMG4 and cause mayhem! Now Mario and SMG4 have to gather a gang of losers to take him down.
Mario attempts the very difficult task of screwing in a light bulb.
13
October 28, 2023
AHHHHHHH IT'S WOTFI 2023! And we did something VERY different this year. SMG4 & SMG3 have to infiltrate Marty's casino but Mario is his bodyguard and has riddled the casino with traps! We got the fans to vote and help plan out what to do... and the choices they make affect the WOTFI and ending! LETS SEE HOW IT ALL PLAYS OUT!
14
October 19, 2024
WOTFI IS HEREEEE!!!!! And Mr. Puzzles has turned into a literal theme park...
Trivia[]
It is based on Treehouse of Horror in The Simpsons.