In the beginning, Mario has a nightmare about Luigi loving Peach. When Toad says "Hi Mario!" he wakes up screaming and jumps out of the castle. Luigi comes outside, only to find Mario saying stuff. SMG4 then cheers Mario up and helps Mario get a date with Peach. But, due to Mario's stupidity, SMG4 becomes frustrated and rejects helping Mario. Mario then goes to Merlon and asks him if he could help his problem. Merlon makes a "love" potion to which can maybe change Peach's thoughts about Mario. So Mario gets the love potion, goes back to the castle and tries it out. And instead, it drives Peach insane. When Mario comes back inside, SMG4 greets him and asks Mario where has he been. Mario told SMG4 about the love potion, then Luigi comes inside (with no legs) and tells the guys about Peach. Mario and SMG4 come outside, only to find a gigantic Peach on the castle. Mario tries to apologize to Peach for what he has put her through and gets his head blasted. SMG4 then hosts a game show where he asks Mario and Peach questions. Mario wins the game, only to have Peach rage and take Mario up to the roof of the castle. SMG4 helped save Mario by shooting Peach with an arrow. In the end, Peach forgave Mario by asking him out on a date, but Mario refused, considering that Peach almost killed him. This explains why Mario hates Peach as he says so at the end.
