The Lie that was the cake that is a Lie is remake of SMG4's first blooper, The Cake Is a Lie!.
Story
Princess Peach sends a letter to Mario, which is an invitation to come to the castle and have some cake. Mario gets stuck in the warp pipe, because he's too fat. After, Mario manages to get himself out of the pipe, but he jumps too high. Mario tries some gymnastics to come out of the pipe without problems. Mario goes to the castle, but Lakitu stops him because he ate 472 cakes. Mario imagines drowning Lakitu and throwing him against the wall, but Lakitu wakes him. When Mario enters the castle, Toad says that the princess is captured. Mario thinks that the princess is in the castle and Toad lies. While Mario searches for the princess, Luigi finds him naked. Luigi says that Peach is kidnapped by Bowser, however Mario is more interested about the cake than Peach. This leads Mario to search for Bowser, who Mario defeats with only a punch. After Bowser is defeated, a Power Star appears which transforms Mario to Wing Mario. A short time after he starts to fly, all his magic powers disappear causing him to fall. Princess Peach is at the front of the castle saying that the power of the Stars is restored to the castle. Mario grows up at a huge size and explodes into a coin from his rage. Princess says that they have to do something special for Mario, causing the coin to transform into Mario. With all of this, Peach reveals that the cake hasn't even been cooked yet, making Mario going crazy and killing him in a similar fashion to "The Cake Is a Lie!". Mario explodes again.
Characters
- Mario
- Princess Peach
- Toad
- Luigi
- Bowser minor
- Lakitu
- King Bob-omb Cameo
Trivia
- Bowser and Luigi don't appear in the original blooper.